Screenshot Only Does Active Window, even tho "Entire Screen" is set to default

I'm using Zorin Lite, Xfce4-screenshooter.
I have to hold shift + screenshot key and select the entire screen.
Even though "Entire Screen" is set to default.
How do I make it take a screenshot of the entire screen?

Check Settings -> Keyboard -> Application Shortcuts, and search for xfce4-screenshooter. The default command for Print should indeed to capture the full screen, but if it's not you can change it back to that: