hmm... I do both it only takes some min. to change it via scripts.
The first one for me is sharper to view?
It's sharper, but the second one is not bad either.
The second is ... not golden enough
I have now 3 variations of gold....
If at some point you want to make icons with metal effect, this one have a good balance between colors/light/shadow.
But, in fact, I don't know if they would be as pleasant to the eyes as the ones you built. Your icons are so friendly-eye.
You won't be able to please everyone
Silver. I can't seem to hit the bronze right - so no bronze.
Perfect!
The problem with metallic colors is that the texture defines the appearance of metallicity (Or how we identify it as metallic) more than the actual wavelength of light.
reach letter "E" in the apps.
Also is this gold or bronze?
It is whichever the viewer wants it to be.
I see it as bronze in normal light or gold in low light.
With more icons together is better to see, but I think it's bronze.
I'm running a contest to win the Alien Icon theme - [Shop] Storm's Icon Collection - #7 by Storm
Also I'm half way through the apps icons of my Nordic Icon set.
I am new here, but have to say you have great talent. Your icons are beautiful and practical. Very nice!
This I really like!